Johnathan Otto `John` Earl
Johnathan Otto `John` Earl , Age 85
Johnathan Otto "John" Earl, age 85, of Baraboo, passed away on Tuesday, November 18, 2025 at SSM Health St. Clare Hospital with family by his side.
Johnathan, son of Fern and Alma (West) Earl, was born in Wayne, OH on December 21, 1939. He attended St. Stephen's Lutheran school in Adrian, MI and graduated from Michigan Lutheran Seminary in Saginaw, MI. John furthered his studies by obtaining a bachelor's degree in education from Dr. Martin Lutheran College in New Ulm, MN. John was a dedicated educator his entire career; he taught at St. John's Lutheran School in Baraboo, Centennial Lutheran and Risen Christ, both in Milwaukee, as well as Salem Lutheran in Owosso, MI.
As a Principle, Teacher and Coach, he poured his whole heart into every lesson in the classroom, on the court or on the field. He met each day with enthusiasm that lifted his students and colleagues alike. Many students, his son and daughter included, loudly and proudly say that he was one of the best and their favorite Teacher and Coach. John was always there with a prayer, listening ear, ready guidance, and a warm smile. He led with Christian strength, empathy, and such understanding that it created a place where every student felt seen, supported and inspired.
On June 8, 1963, he was united in marriage to Barbara Jean Egerer at St. John's Lutheran Church in Baraboo. He was above all, a family man. His love for his wife, Barb, and his children ran deep, steady and unwavering. That love only grew with the arrival of his grandchildren. Each one holds a special place in his heart. He leaves behind memories touched with love, growth, quiet truths and a lot of laughter.
John was proud to have served on the Board of Control at Wisconsin Lutheran High School in Milwaukee, worked on the Sauk County Board of Supervisors, and he was President of the Central Wisconsin Community Action Council for 25 years, the council helped to lift people out of poverty into a better quality of life. When not working, volunteering his time, gardening, watching the Green Bay Packers or Wisconsin Badgers, John was seen sitting on the porch talking to neighbors enjoying the midwest summer weather.
He quietly and humbly supported so many organizations such as: Operation Smile, Smile Train for Cleft Lip and Palate Children, Heritage Foundation, Alliance Defending Freedom, CareNet Ministry, St. Labre Indian School Foundation, St. Judes and ASPSA just to name a few.
He is survived by his loving wife of 62 years, Barb of Baraboo; children, Steven (Jennifer) Earl of Baraboo and Deborah of LaCrescent, MN; five grandchildren, Taylor (Erik) Hebble, Brandon Steele, Elliana Schoeller, Tyler Earl, and Piper Earl; one great-granddaughter, Callie Anderson; as well as his sister, Linda K. (Howard) Hunt of Fairfield, IA; sister-in-law, Janyce of Gainesville, GA; nieces, nephews, other relatives and friends.
He was preceded in death by his parents; his brother, William J. Earl and nephew, Scott Earl.
Funeral Services for John will be held on Tuesday, November 25, 2025 at 11 a.m. at St. John's Lutheran Church in Baraboo with Pastor Tim Kuske officiating. Visitation will be held on Monday, November 24, 2025 from 4 p.m. until 7 p.m. at Redlin-Ertz Funeral Home and at the church on Tuesday, from 10 a.m. until the time of service. Burial will follow at Walnut Hill Cemetery. Memorials may be made to St. John's Lutheran Church or School in John's name.
Condolences
Jeffery Exferd November 20, 2025
Former student/family friend Belton , Texas
Mrs. Earl, Steve, Deborah and family. I’m deeply sorry for your loss and prayers from my family to yours. Mr. Earl was a true blessing and mentor since my days at Centennial. I have been blessed to have his presence in my life. Peace be with you all.
Laura Adamczyk Schaper November 20, 2025
Former Student Onalaska, WI , Wisconsin
Mr. Earl was my favorite grade schoolteacher and the reason I became a teacher myself. I loved the days where he would read us a novel all day, and how he let me stay after school and help with schoolwork or clean erasers. I was blessed to run into him at Baraboo High School a few years ago and got to give him a hug. I would often think of him as I drove past Baraboo on my trips to Milwaukee. Some of my best school memories were from my two years as his student. Well done, good and faithful servant!
Chris November 20, 2025
Teacher West Allis , Wisconsin
My condolences to Mrs. Earl, Steve, Deborah & family. Although I hadn’t seen Mr. Earl in years, I will always cherish the memories. He was definitely the best teacher I ever had
Sue November 20, 2025
Friend of Deborah La Crescent , Minnesota
My dear friend Deb--my heart aches for you and your family. It's always hard to lose someone you love, especially when that person has been your guiding light your entire life. Good memories and sweet stories come into our lives like pennies from heaven-reminding us in small, unexpected ways that we loved and have been loved. Wishing you blessings of love and the comfort of peace each time you remember your Dad. Love, Sue
Brenda Emery November 20, 2025
Friend, co-worker North Freedom , Wisconsin
John & I worked together at the Berry Farmer!! He was constantly joking around and I learned very quickly how to dish it back...lol He was a ray of sunshine. I'll miss his smile. What a beautiful person. Prayers for comfort & peace during this time for his family. Enjoyed getting to know Barb too?? Rest easy John.
Joe November 20, 2025
Friend of Deborah La Crosse , Wisconsin
I wish to extend my deepest condolences to Deborah, Mrs Barb Earl and the entire family. I remember meeting John briefly many years ago. . He impressed me with a quiet confidence and soft smile , a common feature of genuinely kind men. I am sorrowed by his passing.
Trina Williams November 20, 2025
Meals on Wheels-Baraboo Sauk City , Wisconsin
I am so sorry to hear of John’s passing! His Meals on Wheels family will miss him! Trina
Dennis and Penny Quandt November 21, 2025
Friends Dothan , AL
We are so sorry to hear of John’s passing. We had such great memories with you and John wonderful man. Love Dennis and Penny Our thoughts and Prayers are with you all.
David Skaife November 21, 2025
Student Laramie , Wyoming
Mr. Earl will be miss by everyone he ever taught, his passion for teaching always shines through. May God wrap him in his loving arms and keep him watching over his loved ones. Please know my thoughts and prayers are with you all.
Gary and Georgia Schara November 21, 2025
Dear friend and Mentor Kalispell , Montana
Our deep felt condolences to Barb and Family. What wonderful man ! I remember all the Stories Gary would tell of his best teacher ever when we were dating . He got him interested in football and sports .Then I met Mr Earl. And knew exactly what a special person he was . Showing his Christian love care concern and gentleness to all ! Was quite yet funny .His smile lit up the room and touched your heart. Best Teacher Coach mentor and friend . We are so Blessed have known John
Gwen Landers November 21, 2025
Former student Menomonie , Wisconsin
Mr. Earl was an awesome teacher and coach! He was also a very kind and faith filled man. Many of my siblings had him for a teacher and coach while we attended St. John’s. We all have always spoken of him being “the best teacher”. God’s blessings to his wife and children and grandchildren.
Hillarie Higgins November 21, 2025
Student Milwaukee , Wisconsin
I had Mr. Earl for 6th grade at St Johns and he remains the best teacher I’ve ever had. He did truly pour his heart out to help children and those in need but he was also incredibly funny with an infectious smile. He will be so missed here but I believe he is now home. My heart goes out to his family as they cope with this enormous loss and may God bless them.
Robbi Zimmerman November 22, 2025
Friend Baraboo , Wisconsin
So Sorry your loss Barb & family !!! He was always so nice to me ! Always had a smile !!!